Tiles on the third floor start to come loose four weeks after installation. The site manager calls the contractor, who promises to come "next week." Three months later nothing has happened, and in the dispute there is no proof of what was reported and when. A proper defect notice under VOB/B (known in German as Mängelrüge) prevents exactly that. It puts the defect on record, sets a deadline and prepares the ground for substitute performance.
Two triggers, two provisions
A defect notice is the client's request that the contractor remedy a specifically described defect within a deadline. VOB/B, the German standard terms for construction contracts, distinguishes by timing. The dividing line is acceptance: the client's declaration that the work is accepted as essentially in conformity with the contract (§ 12 VOB/B, § 640 BGB, the German Civil Code).
- Before acceptance (§ 4(7) VOB/B): Work that is recognized as defective or non-conforming during execution must be replaced by the contractor at its own cost with conforming work. This is usually called a defect warning. If the contractor is responsible for the defect, damages may be added. If the client sets a reasonable deadline and threatens termination, it can terminate under § 8(3) VOB/B.
- After acceptance (§ 13(5) VOB/B): On request, the contractor must remedy defects that appear within the limitation period, within a reasonable deadline set by the client. The claim to remedy the reported defects becomes time-barred two years after the written request is received, but not before the regular period under § 13(4) VOB/B has expired (four years for buildings, unless agreed otherwise).
This is the economic core of a written notice: for the reported defect, it can extend the limitation period of the remedy claim. How acceptance itself works is covered in Bauabnahme nach VOB/B und BGB: was wirklich zählt.
What belongs in the notice
A defect is a deviation of the actual condition from the agreed or customary condition (§ 13(1) VOB/B, § 633 BGB). For the notice, it is usually enough to describe the visible symptom. You do not need to know the cause. German case law calls this the symptom rule. What matters is that the contractor can tell what to inspect and fix.
A workable notice contains:
- Addressee and contract: contractor, project, trade, contract or order with date.
- Location: floor, room, component, ideally with a reference to the plan.
- Symptom: What is visible or measurable? Example: "Tiles in bathroom 3.04 sound hollow and are loosening at the threshold, joints crack near the shower."
- Evidence: dated photos, dimensions, a reference to the walkthrough report. A photo documentation holds up best when date, location and assignment are clear.
- Request: remedy within a stated deadline, with a date.
- Consequences: announcement of substitute performance at the contractor's expense.
You can find a structure to work from in the template for a defect notice. It does not replace a review of the individual case, but it gives you a complete framework.
The deadline: reasonable, specific, traceable
VOB/B requires a reasonable deadline but names no number. What is reasonable depends on the defect: a leaking connection with ongoing water damage needs a short deadline, rework with material lead time a longer one. Two principles help:
- Use a calendar date instead of "immediately." "By November 27, 2026" can be checked later, "promptly" cannot.
- Match the deadline to the effort. A deadline that is too short is not automatically ineffective, but it usually triggers a reasonable period instead. Setting a realistic deadline from the start avoids the argument.
Distinguish the remedy deadline from a response deadline. You can ask the contractor to name an appointment within a few days and also fix the end of the remedy deadline. That way you get an early reaction and a clear end date.
Prove receipt
A declaration takes effect once it is received by the addressee (§ 130 BGB). In a dispute, the party relying on it has to prove receipt, which here is the client. A notice that only sits in the outbox does not help.
In practice, these methods work:
- Personal delivery against a signed receipt with date.
- Courier with a record: a person who knows the content delivers the letter and notes date, time and place in writing.
- Registered mail: note that a drop-off registered letter proves the drop-off and a hand-delivery registered letter proves the delivery. Without further documentation, the content remains open to challenge.
- Email with a read receipt only as a supplement. Whether email counts as "written" depends on the contract. Check the form clauses before you rely on it.
Always send the notice and its attachments as one complete set, and keep a copy of the exact set that went out. Then it is clear later what the recipient received.
Announce substitute performance
Substitute performance (Ersatzvornahme) means that the client or a third party remedies the defect at the contractor's expense. Under § 13(5) VOB/B, the client can do this if the contractor does not comply with the request to remedy the defect within the reasonable deadline. The announcement therefore belongs in the letter: "After the deadline expires without result, I will have the defect remedied at your expense." More on the term is in the glossary under Ersatzvornahme.
Substitute performance carries financial risk. Before you act, check whether the notice describes the defect specifically enough, whether the deadline has expired, and whether the contractor is seriously refusing or merely late. For larger amounts, consult legal counsel. This article is not legal advice.
Typical mistakes
- Blanket complaints: "The workmanship is defective overall" names no defect. The contractor cannot remedy anything, and the notice misses its purpose.
- Oral only: A phone call or a remark on site is hard to prove and does not trigger the limitation effect under § 13(5) VOB/B.
- No deadline: A request without a deadline does not prepare substitute performance.
- Wrong addressee: The notice goes to the contracting party, not to the foreman or a subcontractor.
- Stating a cause instead of describing the symptom: "Incorrect installation" is a guess, "cracks in the screed along the door axis" is observable.
- No proof of receipt: The best notice fails if nobody can prove that it arrived.
- Collecting defects instead of reporting them: Waiting until the final invoice costs time and evidence. How defects are managed up to acceptance is shown in Mängelmanagement auf der Baustelle: bis zur Abnahme.
Checklist
- Contracting party, project and trade clearly named.
- Each defect described individually, with location, plan or room reference and symptom.
- Dated photos with location and a reference to the walkthrough report attached.
- Timing checked: before acceptance § 4(7) VOB/B, afterward § 13(5) VOB/B.
- Request to remedy worded with a specific calendar date.
- Substitute performance at the contractor's expense announced.
- Written form and form clauses of the contract checked.
- Delivery method chosen that proves receipt, and a copy of the sent set filed.
- Deadline entered in the calendar, with someone responsible for follow-up.
- After remedy: re-inspection on site documented.
Frequently asked questions
Is an email enough as a written defect notice?
That depends on the contract. § 13(5) VOB/B refers to a written request, and many contracts add form rules. To be safe, also send the notice in a way that proves receipt, such as by courier or against a signed receipt.
Do I need to know the cause of the defect to report it?
Usually not. It is enough to describe the symptom specifically: what is visible or measurable, and where. Finding the cause is the contractor's task, and in a dispute that of an expert.
How long should the deadline in a defect notice be?
VOB/B requires a reasonable deadline and sets no fixed number. The nature and scope of the defect, urgency and procurement times are decisive. A specific calendar date is easier to follow than wording such as "immediately."
What is the difference between a defect warning and a defect notice?
In terms, an objection before acceptance is usually called a defect warning (§ 4(7) VOB/B) and an objection afterward a defect notice (§ 13(5) VOB/B). Both should be written, specific and carry a deadline. Only the written request after acceptance has the special limitation effect of § 13(5) VOB/B.
Conclusion
A defect notice under VOB/B works when it is written, describes the defect specifically, sets a reasonable deadline with a date, announces substitute performance and demonstrably reaches the recipient. Blanket and oral complaints cost evidentiary value in a dispute and possibly claims.
Structify, the software for digital construction documentation, manages defects as tickets with photos, plan location, deadlines and responsibilities, so the notice and its follow-up live in the same project. More under defect management. If you would like to see how this looks on your project, book a short online demo.
